Lady Bagheera
16 August 2025 03:42 pmApparently Soviet Bagheera is female :-)
I hadn't realised this, as the character doesn't actually speak in the various comparison clips I'd seen... and yes, the Soviet version is not only, as advertised, much closer to Kipling -- Kaa is a dangerous ally, not an ineffectual enemy -- but a greater deal darker as a result.
Although to be fair, Disney apparently did originally plan to make a much more 'realistic' version of "The Jungle Book" (at one point I had a tape that included some of the music written for it before the project was abandoned), and made a conscious choice to go for a comedy take on the story that has a lot of charm and good songs in its own right. And it has George Sanders, of course :-)
I hadn't realised this, as the character doesn't actually speak in the various comparison clips I'd seen... and yes, the Soviet version is not only, as advertised, much closer to Kipling -- Kaa is a dangerous ally, not an ineffectual enemy -- but a greater deal darker as a result.
Although to be fair, Disney apparently did originally plan to make a much more 'realistic' version of "The Jungle Book" (at one point I had a tape that included some of the music written for it before the project was abandoned), and made a conscious choice to go for a comedy take on the story that has a lot of charm and good songs in its own right. And it has George Sanders, of course :-)
no subject
Date: 2025-09-11 09:26 am (UTC)(I'm not sure, on reflection, quite sure why it *does* end in "a", given that so far as I remember the chap's actual title was "Vlad Dracul"...)
For some reason I am irresistably reminded of the extremely silly video YouTube decided to show me... https://youtube.com/watch?v=aygZBk81h3g
(It made more sense once I'd managed to track down Stierlitz on Wikipedia, but I got the gist anyway ;-p)
--We have a Tiger in the bathroom!
--So what? a tiger is just a big kitty-cat (кошка)
--It's not a кошка, it's a Tiger tank! :-P
Yes, the overall impression I got was that the translators simply wanted to add more female voices to the cast...
We were assured of it at the time by our (elderly -- probably White Russian) teacher when being told about noun-endings, and I had no reason to doubt her... but come to think of it, we never actually *saw* any of those press articles ;-)
That sort of thing would have been way beyond our abilities to read at that stage, of course.
Now I'm reminded of the jokes about "Dartanyan" clearly being Caucasian :-P
(Also based on Boyarsky's appearance, I think: the dark coloration, high cheekbones and slightly slanted green eyes of his d'Artagnan do look a bit 'Armenian'...)
no subject
Date: 2025-09-11 10:50 pm (UTC)Ah, if she was a White Russian, it might explain it. It makes sense for them to be out of loop regarding the use of Russian language in the Soviet Union.