"Liberté", Gita Trelease
10 July 2024 04:43 amI have very mixed feelings about this book. The premise in itself intrigued me (a parallel-universe French Revolution where magic is real and it is magicians being blamed for crop failures and strung up from lamp-posts), and the idea of a magic system based on *sorrow* is very original; it both leads to magic being associated with suffering for the user, thus making its use less inviting, and, humans being what they are, gives rise to the temptation to develop techniques for mining the suffering of other people to fuel your own power, thus giving magicians in general a bad name.( Read more... )
My main gripe with it is that the book turned out to be very clearly flavoured as a 'Young Adult' novel. If you want to write Strong Independent Female Leads, the French Revolution is a pretty good place to do it, and I've read a couple of seriously good historical novels by women writers that do just that: Hilary Mantel's "A Place of Greater Safety" and Madge Pierce's "City of Darkness, City of Light". But this book simply doesn't convince on that level. ( Read more... )
My main gripe with it is that the book turned out to be very clearly flavoured as a 'Young Adult' novel. If you want to write Strong Independent Female Leads, the French Revolution is a pretty good place to do it, and I've read a couple of seriously good historical novels by women writers that do just that: Hilary Mantel's "A Place of Greater Safety" and Madge Pierce's "City of Darkness, City of Light". But this book simply doesn't convince on that level. ( Read more... )